بِسمِ اللهِ الرَّحْمَنِ الرَّحِيمِ

Allah, in the name of, the Most Affectionate, the Eternally Merciful

Personality Development Program

Contribute to humanity by develop a God-oriented personality!!!

تعمیر شخصیت پروگرام

ایک خدا پرست شخصیت کی تعمیر کر کے انسانیت کی خدمت کیجیے!!!

Search the Website New

اردو اور عربی تحریروں کو ڈاؤن لوڈ کرنے کے لئے نستعلیق فانٹ یہاں سے ڈاؤن لوڈ کیجیے۔

Home

Different between Academic and Propagandistic Writings

 

اردو ورژن کے لئے یہاں کلک کیجیے

Religion & Ethics

Personality Development

Islamic Studies

Quranic Arabic Learning

Adventure & Tourism

Risk Management

Your Questions & Comments

Urdu & Arabic Setup

About the Founder

Download the Article in PDF Version

Based on our experience with different types of writings, we can classify those under two categories: Serious academic writings and propagandistic ones. The objective of this essay is to establish criteria to differentiate between the two. The following comparison and contrast will help us in doing so:

 

 

Academic Writings

Propagandistic Writings

Purpose

The purpose of academic writings is to share ideas of the writer to his audience in a decent and positive manner in order to invoke thinking.

The purpose of propagandistic writings is to convince the audience on ideas of the writer by all possible means.

Tone

Tone of academic writings is positive. Even if it is essential to provide some negative information, it is presented in carefully in a positive way.

Tone of propagandistic writings is overtly negative and sometimes highly negative.

Respect for others

The author demonstrates signs of respect for those to whom he disagrees.

The author demonstrates signs of disrespect for those to whom he disagrees.

Manipulation of arguments

The author does not twist or manipulate the arguments.

The author twists or manipulates the arguments.

Hiding facts and arguments

The author does not ignore any argument or fact even if it weakens his viewpoint.

The author ignores the facts and arguments which weaken his viewpoint and presents only those which supports his claim.

Manipulation of reader

The author does not manipulate the reader and considers it as a moral crime.

The author attempts to manipulate the reader and considers it morally legitimate to achieve a bigger objective.

Use of emotional phrases

Use of emotional phrases is limited and calculated.

Use of emotional phrases is abundant.

Style of argument

The author raises questions on the viewpoint he is refuting and does not pass any judgment.

The author passes direct and bold judgments on the viewpoint and the personalities he is refuting.

Discussing intentions

The author never discusses personality of others.

The author discusses even hidden facts like intentions of others.

Type of writings

Serious books and articles are written in academic style.

Polemic books, blogs and articles are written in propagandistic style. Newspaper articles are often propagandistic in nature.

Thoroughness

Academic writers present a thorough analysis of their arguments.

Analysis provided by propagandistic writers often lacks thoroughness and depth. The author is so busy in writing and communicating that he does not give enough time to thinking and analyzing the issue under discussion.

Target of criticism

There is no target, which is severely criticized.

A person, group or nation is target of severe criticism and rebuttal.

Ridicule

The author never makes a ridicule of his opponents and it is considered a serious crime.

Ridicule and witty language is very common.

Describing opponent's viewpoints

Academic writers describe opposing viewpoints in their correct and original form.

Propagandistic writers attempt to portray the darkest possible picture of opposing viewpoints.

Use of 'they'

Use of 'us' is frequent and that of 'they' is minimal.

Use of 'they' and 'us' is too frequent.

Staunchness

Academic writers are expected to be flexible in their views. They should be willing to change their views, if they found better evidence in support of the opposite viewpoint.

Propagandistic writers consider impeccable staunchness as a positive attribute and outspokenly praise their conviction in their viewpoint.

Double standards

Academic writers do not use double standards for evaluating different views.

Propagandists often use double standards for their friends and foes.

Nature of phrases used

Sentences are often mild, pleasant and calm. The author does not attempt to force the reader to accept his viewpoint.

Sentences are often very strong, harsh, self-asserting and aggressive. The author attempts to force the reader to accept his viewpoint.

Examples of phrases used

Following phrases are common in academic writings:

Following phrases are common in academic writings:

·    Evidence indicates …

·          It is clearly proven….

·    It is substantiated by….

·          It is a clear proof of….

·    We did not find it correct….

·          It is wrong ….

·    We do not doubt his integrity…

·          He is culprit, criminal ….

·    The view X sounds more plausible than Y.

·          The view Y is self-contradictory ….

·    We respect their view

·          They are our enemy….

·    We think that the view X is not correct….

·          We accuse them to be heretic, deviated from the right path….

·    It is possible…

·          I strongly believe …

·    It is difficult to believe..

·          I cannot believe…

·    I appreciate ….

·          I discourage…

Impact on readers

Academic writings have a positive impact on reader's mind and they are highly effective in producing the desired result i.e. provoking thinking. Opponents are sometimes also convinced by the arguments provided by the author.

Readers often take propagandist writings negatively and are rarely convinced. Such writings only convince those readers who are already convinced on the views presented by the author. Opponents often read them for further refutation.

Behavior of writers

Academic writers often pen in academic style but sometimes, they also write in propagandistic style.

It is very hard for a propagandistic writer to write in academic style, so academic writings of propagandists are rare.

 

The above-mentioned details are applicable to other genres like film, drama, documentaries, novels, talk shows etc. However, you will find majority of them as propagandistic and it is very hard to find a film, drama, documentary, novel and talk show produced in academic style.

Based on the above, I would like to advise you the following:

·       While reading a book, article etc. determine whether it is academic or propagandistic.

·       Focus on academic writings and ignore the propagandistic ones.

·       If you do not find academic writings on a subject and only propagandistic writings are available, try to find some writings of the opponent and form your opinions after reading the both.

·       While analyzing the propagandistic writings, differentiate between verifiable arguments and non-verifiable arguments. Focus on the first and ignore the second. For instance, especially articles written on political subjects in newspapers, intelligence reports or oral claims of eye-witnesses are provided as an evidence which could not be verified. A clear-cut proof is the one which is easily verifiable.

·       Whenever you write a book or an article, try to pen in academic style. Rational readers reject propagandistic styles and mark a red circle around the name of the author. So be careful, writing in propagandistic style may adversely affect your reputation.

I try my best to write in academic style. However, you may find propagandistic tone in some sentences. You are highly encouraged to identify such sentences and let me know so that I can improve them.

(Author: Muhammad Mubashir Nazir)

Share your views, comments and questions by sending an email at mubashirnazir100@gmail.com.

Think about it!

·       Analyze the psychological aspect of academic and propagandistic writings. What are the psychological reasons to adopt each style?

·       Based on your studies, identify three academic and three propagandistic writings and compare their attributes.

·       How could you identify propagandistic writings? Describe three of their visible symbols.

·       What is the harm of reading propagandistic writings?

·       Whether the majority of English writings is academic or propagandistic? Answer in the light of your past reading.

Send your comments and questions by email to publish them on this webpage.

Download the Article in PDF Version

 

Unit 1: Relation with God & His Prophets

In the name of God, the most Beneficent, the Eternally Merciful     |     The Treasure’s Map     |     The Month of Ramadan: What to achieve?     |     The Prophet’s Love     |     The Basic Premise of the Religion     |     Who is like You?     |     Pure Monotheism I     |     Pure Monotheism II     |     Who deserves the Paradise?

Unit 2: Elimination of our Negative Personality

How to get rid of Poverty?     |     The Report of Transparency International and a Hadith     |     Justification or Admitting One’s Fault     |     Artificial Colors of Glamour     |     Religious People & Ostentation      |     Character of Ancient Religious Leaders at Jerusalem     |     Attachment to a Group is irrelevant for Success     |     Successful Life     |     The Revolution Occurred!     |     Form & Spirit     |     Jealousy & Modern Testing Techniques     |     How to overcome Procrastination?

     |     The Difference between an Extremist & a Moderate Person

Unit 3: Development of our Positive Personality

The Quranic Strategy for Personality Development     |     How to get rid of Poverty?

     |     Character builds the Nation     |     The Sermon of Mount     |     Success: What is it?     |     Success Secrets     |     A Positive Attitude affirms the Life     |     Road Block     |     Thinking after Writing!     |     Trust is Golden     |     Getting off to a good start     |     The Lesson of Arnold Schwarzenegger     |     Unlocking the Gates to Success     |     Admitting One’s Fault     |     Top 10 Qualities of Excellence

Unit 4: Relationship with Human Beings

Backbiting     |     Suspicion     |     Defamation     |     Examining Others with Suspicion     |     Are you killing your family?

Unit 5: Our Responsibility, Vision & Mission

The Love of Prophet Muhammad with Knowledge     |     Traditional Mentality     |     Strange Similarities between Christian & Muslim Histories     |     The Relationship of Revelation & Intellect (Part I)     |     The Relationship of Revelation & Intellect (Part II)     |     The Problem of Aurengzeb Alamgir

 

Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: web site hit counter